Trial Report · Season 2021/22

Zimbabwe Leaf Tobacco Trials

A small-scale trial in Trelawney on the farm of Isaac Nyakutepa — thirteen trial rows comparing fertilizers, nematicides, insecticides, fungicides and suckericides through a very dry start to the season.

Tobacco trial rows at the Trelawney trial site

Trial at a Glance

Farmer
Isaac Nyakutepa
Grower Number
V185629
Area
Trelawney
Planted
5 November 2021

Why We Run These Trials

Each year Maguires does trials on small-scale farms as well as commercial farms. Our goal is to find the most reliable and cost-effective way to grow a tobacco crop. We use several chemicals and fertilizers and constantly monitor the crop — and at the end of the season we record the weight of the leaves from each row and each reaping and compare the results. This year Syngenta has joined us and will also be conducting some trials with Maguires.

Fertilizers & Chemicals on Trial

Thirteen trial rows, each with its own treatment programme.

RowFertilizerNematicideFert ConditionerTop DressingInsecticidesFungicideSuckericide
1High C 400 kg/ha——A.N 120 kg/haPlesiva Star 270 g/ha · Belt 50 mL/ha—N’Decanol 5 L/ha
2High C 400 kg/ha—Ezyflow Lime 5 L/haA.N 120 kg/haPlesiva Star 270 g/ha · Belt 50 mL/ha—N’Decanol 5 L/ha
3Lime Blend 400 kg/ha——A.N 120 kg/haPlesiva Star 270 g/ha · Belt 50 mL/ha—N’Decanol 5 L/ha
4Lime Blend 400 kg/ha—Ezyflow Lime 5 L/haA.N 120 kg/haPlesiva Star 270 g/ha · Belt 50 mL/ha—N’Decanol 5 L/ha
5High C 400 kg/haAbamiprid 3 L/ha—A.N 120 kg/haBullet 250 mL/ha · Belt 50 mL/ha—N’Decanol 5 L/ha
6High C 400 kg/haAbamiprid ×2 3 L/ha—A.N 120 kg/haBullet 250 mL/ha · Belt 50 mL/ha—N’Decanol 5 L/ha
7High C 400 kg/ha——A.N 120 kg/haImidacloprid 1 L/ha · Bullet 250 mL/ha · Belt 50 mL/haBion 60 g/haN’Decanol 5 L/ha
8High C 400 kg/ha——A.N 120 kg/haImidacloprid 1 L/ha · Bullet 250 mL/ha · Belt 50 mL/haBion ×2 60 g/haN’Decanol 5 L/ha
9High C 400 kg/ha——A.N 120 kg/haImidacloprid 1 L/ha · Bullet 250 mL/ha · Belt 50 mL/haAzoxy Duo ×2 500 mL/haN’Decanol 5 L/ha
10High C 400 kg/ha——A.N 120 kg/haImidacloprid 1 L/ha · Bullet 250 mL/ha · Belt 50 mL/haAzoxy Duo ×3 500 mL/haN’Decanol 5 L/ha
11High C 400 kg/ha——A.N 120 kg/haImidacloprid 1 L/ha · Bullet 250 mL/ha · Belt 50 mL/ha—Flumetralin Duo 2 L/ha
12High C 400 kg/ha——A.N 120 kg/haImidacloprid 1 L/ha · Bullet 250 mL/ha · Belt 50 mL/ha—Flumetralin Duo 3 L/ha
13High C 400 kg/haVS-04 5 L/ha—A.N 120 kg/haImidacloprid 1 L/ha · Bullet 250 mL/ha · Belt 50 mL/ha—N’Decanol 5 L/ha

The Season, Step by Step

The trial was inspected and photographed regularly through the first months of the season.

  1. 5 November 2021

    At planting

    The trial tobacco has been planted in a very sandy area. There is no sign of dusty surface beetle at planting — the land has been cleaned and there are no old tobacco stalks.

    Planting the trial tobacco into sandy ground
    Planting crew in the sandy trial land
  2. 23 November 2021

    Standing, but dry

    All the tobacco is standing but the land is very dry and in need of rain. There is no sign of cutworm or dusty surface beetle affecting the crop. Plesiva Star has been used on half the crop, and Imidacloprid on the other half.

    Dry trial rows in late November
    Young plants standing in very dry soil
  3. 30 November 2021

    Still insect-free

    The farmer is yet to receive rain, but the crop is still insect free. There is no sign of any insect damage throughout all the tobacco, including the farmer’s own crop.

    Healthy young plant with no insect damage
    Dry trial rows with clean plants
  4. 17 December 2021

    A good start

    It has been a good start to the trials — there is no sign of any plants dying. Although the tobacco has all taken, it is yet to receive any rain.

    Trial sign for row 2 in the dry field
    Established plant waiting for rain
  5. 5 January 2022

    Rain at last

    The farmer received some rainfall and the tobacco has shot up. There is still no sign of aphids, and the majority of the plants took and are still standing.

    Trial rows shooting up after the first rainfall
    Trial sign for row 10 in the growing crop
    Healthy plant after the rain
  6. January 2022

    Stink bug next door — not in the trial

    There appears to be stink bug damage in the farmer’s crop next to the trial area, but no leaves in the trial area have been damaged.

    Undamaged leaves in the trial area
  7. January 2022

    Potassium firing in the area

    Potassium firing has been a major problem throughout small-scale crops in the area.

    Leaf showing potassium firing symptoms
    Close-up of potassium firing on a leaf
  8. January 2022

    First aphids

    Aphids have started to appear on the crop. The Plesiva Star is due its next spray, which is being done now.

    Aphids appearing at the leaf axil

Key Finding

Planted into very sandy ground and waiting until January for its first real rain, the trial crop stayed insect-free — even with stink bug damage in the farmer’s crop right next to the trial area.